The Class Couple
  • HOME
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Read
  • Our Home
  • Shop

got skills?

12/29/2014

3 Comments

 
Picture
Hey everyone! Greg here. When I first started the blog with Becky, I never realized how difficult it would be to keep up with posting! Becky is much more diligent with the posts, for which I am very thankful.
When I heard that the College Board was introducing a new format for AP US History (APUSH for short) this year, I was genuinely excited that real change could happen with my course organization. I first started teaching APUSH in 2009. I reinforced the test format with the drudgery of countless multiple choice questions focused on minutia from over 400+ years of American history. Students who were strong at deductive reasoning excelled at the MC questions while others, who were still extremely bright, floundered in the wake of those tests/quizzes. I supplemented with as much writing as I could, but couldn’t ignore that 50% of the AP exam score was derived from MC questions. My grade book looked like almost every other grade book: it was organized by assignment - Quiz A, Homework C, Test 1, Project 1.2, etc. It was what I was taught, so it is what I did.
Picture
Yes, this is a screenshot from last year's grade book.
So when the CollegeBoard presented the new course outline, I was ecstatic at the potential of focusing on “historical thinking skills”. The refocus gave me an opportunity to try something new. Rather than allow the content drive the grade, I could flip it and make the skill the center of the discussion. This concept is completely appropriate, perhaps the norm, in the early elementary grades. Becky’s report card, for example, consists of 32 academic skills and 8 social & work habits. Subsequently, her grade book includes scores for some of the following indicators: applies vowel sounds, applies letter knowledge, solves addition facts, recalls addition facts, et.al. This allows Becky to have a much more accurate read on student performance and more importantly - student understanding and growth. Although I essentially was checking for skills within my tasks, students and parents were unable to determine what they were truly gaining from the course. 
How could I apply the practical grading procedures from the elementary setting to my AP US History course? The CollegeBoard identified 9 historical thinking skills that all students should be proficient in when interacting with the content. 
Picture
With the support of administration, I organized my grade book around the 9 thinking skills with one additional category of "semester project". Each skill would be scored out of a base of 100, as each are viewed as equally important to becoming a well rounded historical thinker. 
To make sure that every "assessment" holds an equal value, every question on a quiz, test, or activity is paired to a skill. So there is no total score for a test, simply a compilation of results targeting a handful of skills.
Picture
Picture
I designate the skill on the assessment. Students know what they need to target.
I also have a lot of questions that allow students to mind map their response. I try to promote non-linear thinking, and the student response has been positive. Below is a question from my last exam. A student response follows.
Picture
Picture
Each skill question is scored on the base of a 100. They are marked against a rubric. I used the description standard from the CollegeBoard as my "Exemplary" column on the rubric. The remainder of the scoring sections work back from there. 
Picture
This is a screenshot of the skill description from the CollegeBoard.
Picture
The rubric is broken down in to general terms to allow for some leeway in the grading. "Exemplary" generally means above a 90%, "proficient" is between a 80% - 89%, "progressing is between a 70% - 79%, and "not meeting expectations" is between a 55% - 69%. I believe students shouldn't receive scores lower than that. If they are continually having problems, we need to work together to strategically improve their skill base. 
Students always have the option to develop a skill. They need to designate a skill to work on, meet with me on strategies to build that skill, and then develop an answer to a prompt targeting that skill. I grade it against the rubric like any other question. 
Student response has been extremely positive. Although almost every student agrees this is extremely difficult, many students have commented that they can identify "what they're learning".  One of our best discussions came at the end of the first marking period. I projected the following image on the board.
Picture
This was the skill average across all students at the end of the marking period. Students immediately said, "Wow, I guess we need to work on historical argumentation." It was the first time I realized the potential for organizing my grade book and assessments in this way. Students were thoughtfully reflecting on their learning, and how to develop a specific skill. Rather than the question "How do I improve my grade?", students asked "How can I improve a skill?". Are there flaws? Yes. Are there things I want to improve in the system for next semester? Yes. But I am really proud of pushing my students to focus on to their thinking and not just a grade. 

-Greg
3 Comments
Peter Pappas link
6/23/2015 09:11:02 am

Hi Greg,
A fascinating approach to building historical skills. And certainly quite useful for the students - here’s the skills, here’s the tasks, the rubric - now lets start measuring your progress. I especially like this student observation "Wow, I guess we need to work on historical argumentation." It gets at the heart of students learning to monitor their own progress and becoming life long learners.

While I think that sports analogies can be overused - I’ll bet this approach matches the quantification of game stats and goal setting the arises from teams seeing their weak points and the strengths of their opponents. Curious if you have more responses from your students. It would be interesting to see how they reacted to this approach. Also the parent - since they are used to the old style report card.

This approach reminds me of what we did in a summer transition program for kids going into high school. It was years ago, but we used “primitive” online survey to allow them to diagnose the groups weaknesses and invited the students to help design the resulting curriculum. Here’s a piece I published Take a Skills Snapshot: Employing Online Self-Assessments http://peterpappas.com/journals/mms.htm

PS I really like who Becky and you have teamed up on The Class Couple - secondary has so much to learn from elementary. (Becky, when I became a K-12 coordinator and finally explored elementary classrooms I was surprised at all the great teaching and learning going on.)

Reply
Greg Wimmer
6/28/2015 08:16:42 am

Peter,
Thanks so much for reaching out! This attempt at driving the learning through skills, rather than content, has pushed students to think on a completely different level. Their ability to recognize areas of weakness and drill through specific skills has allowed for a lot of growth.

I agree that the sports analogy is a bit cliche, but I'm going to extend it as well. As athletes focus on specific things in practice, those skills begin to improve. Areas that did not see such an intense workout, however, started to weaken. So how do we get students to maintain a high level of thinking while also improving areas that need attention? That's where I need to get better at coaching students through new concepts and generating different perspectives with already "mastered" skills.

Reply
Annie Fischer link
11/5/2023 08:57:44 pm

Thiss was great to read

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture
    Picture

    Mr. & Mrs.

    We are Becky and Greg from York, PA. Becky just started her 13th year of teaching first grade. Greg is a high school social studies teacher. We love teaching and this blog is a peek into our world. 

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    GoNoodle Inspiration Blog
    Picture

    the library

    June 2019
    March 2019
    August 2018
    February 2018
    September 2017
    August 2017
    January 2017
    October 2016
    July 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014

    Picture

    tag, you're it!

    All
    Adding
    Alphabet
    Apush
    Assessments
    Authentic
    Becky
    Becky & Greg
    Cause & Effect
    Children's Literature
    Classroom
    Classroom Community
    Classroom Management
    Classroom Tour
    Columbus
    Craftivity
    Criticalthinking
    Currently
    Doubles Facts
    Fact Families
    Fire Safety
    Five For Friday
    George Washington
    GoNoodle
    Graphing
    Greater Than And Less Than
    Greg
    Halloween
    Highfrequencywords
    How To
    Instagram
    Journeys
    Makingconnections
    Math
    Movie Making
    Numbers
    Perspective
    Phonics
    Primary Sources
    Project Based Learning
    Pumpkins
    Purpose
    QR Codes
    Raise Responsibility
    Reading
    Scholastic Book Orders
    Spelling
    Summer
    Summer Prep
    Teachers Pay Teachers
    Technology
    Time
    Twitter
    Videos
    Writing

    Picture

    subscribe

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner



    Blog Design by Alexis Sanchez ©
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.